You and I may not agree on Meyer for Span, but you definitely have a point here. I think at point, simply admitting where you are (and committing to it) would have been beneficial. Rebuilds are risky things, and when Span and Revere were traded, this signified to me at least that this is where the club was going... but you're right in that they didn't go all in here. I think there's something to be said for what value could have been gotten. I suspect there was little out there for Hammer and Suzuki. I was pleasantly surprised for what they got for Doumit, but that return is now in another organization as it wasn't very good... But Perkins... I have a tough time believing we couldn't have gotten something similar to Meyer, or a bat a higher level, for Perk.
The flip side to this approach is that there are a lot of minor league FAs getting time in MN while the prospects develop, especially if those buy low 1 year deals fail (as many do) and the ones that succeed are traded at the deadline. Believe it or not, committing to it would likely have put an even worse product on the field than what we saw last year. Personally, I'm not necessarily against that, because if you're going to be bad, you may as well do it the way Houston did and get the first overall pick to get the best overall talent. Question to me is whether or not the Pohlads or the fans were OK with that...
I think you're right on this though... They should have made a plan and stuck with it. That is where the front office failure is magnified. I don't see how they could have built a competitive team through FA given the holes they had, and I don't think Ryan saw that either.