Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Platoon

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    5,830

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    6

 Content Type 

Profiles

News

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospects Ranking

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

Minnesota Twins Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

The Minnesota Twins Players Project

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Platoon

  1. Platoon
    We just had this discussion before dinner on Xmas day. While the rumors are simply rumors, I have heard them floating around. Neither Sano's weight nor leg are heading in the right direction. While I don't know if it's true, there hasn't been any glowingly positive reports either. IF this is true, Sanos value is greatly diminished. But if someone is willing to take a flyer on his leg, physical condition discipline, and his ability to stay at third for several years, I would move him in a heartbeat. I was always a big fan of his, I could not wait to see him up, but I just cannot see a path forward where he remains consistently healthy.
  2. Platoon
    I like Napoli, but not enough to sign him for this team. For one thing, Vargas or no Vargas, who I also like, we may end up with Sano as a full time DH for quite some time. I have heard some negative reports on his leg, and his training. That would have to be a consideration. Plus, in this day of a short bench, any non versatile PH type is almost a luxury which I doubt the Twins have room for.
  3. Platoon
    The good thing about Darvish is that he is likely better than Lynn and Cobb. The bad thing is there is only one of him. A question I have is IF you could sign Lynn and Cobb for the same amount of money, would that added real depth in the rotation be equal to one Darvish. The current and future Darvish, not the past one? Darvish is likely no longer a true league wide ace. I am not even sure of an answer to the above, but the thought lingers. As for Kintlzer. IF using the term closer means "your best reliever", then the question I always ask is "can you be considered a great team with Kintzler as your closer"? I don't think so. One could also say that question could apply to the Darvish issue. Who would have thought baseball could be so complicated.
  4. Platoon
    In the Mauer perfect storm analogy you missed maybe the biggest piece of that puzzle. The new Target Field. The promise of much needed new revenue which of course would be used to retain and obtain talent. Add that to the equation, and the Twins got off cheap. I could care less about JP money except for the fact he will only dole out so much. Rolling all your dice on Darvish might give you that one big game in Oct., if you get to Oct. signing two really solid 2-3 guys would with this teams offense and OF defense seem a safer bet. It's a tough call, Falvine is really going to earn his money on this one.
  5. Platoon
    They are betwixt the Rock and hard place. IF they could pull off the deal mentioned above, I would certainly pull the pin. It doesn't seem like Gordon has enough glove for SS, and the team remarkably has some options in the MI. And, while no one likes to operate from a point of weakness, and certainly would not admit it, I doubt anyone in MLB will read the following. Which is, this team is in a tough spot, a sold core of position players but with a non complimentary goroup of pitchers. They also don't have an endless inventory of replacement position players. Meaning they will be soon approaching now or never territory. Not only are they not dealing from a position of strength, they only have so many attractive assets to move. They better get it right the first time.
  6. Platoon
    A well deserved thanks to all the Mods. Also to TD for being a safe haven for civil discourse!
  7. Platoon
    I can understand both this, and that bird guys comments. And that's the trouble with this whole argument/analysis. There are so many "what ifs". So here's another one: What if Falvine not only took into consideration the teams likelihood of a WC spot, but also came to a conclusion that The players he gave up were not exactly going to be necessary to reach that relatively low bar. And if I remember correctly Kintzler is a FA. plus we received $500k in pool momey? Falvine is paid to come to these assumptions, way earlier and with much more at stake than I am. The bottom line, is taking the trades off the table, we still end up losing to NY (as usual) and we don't have Kintzler, the trade, and the money. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy the discussion. I just cannot see any reasonable action that would have improved our status in the one and done, or our status as we sit here. But I can envision numerous ones that don't.
  8. Platoon
    One could say that critiscims about the FO moves at the deadline did suggest that. While one could argue the definition of "all in", the contention that the teams moves harmed their ultimate landing place would certainly mean the commentators considered the season an opportunity missed. Or as one might, a failure? The alternative analysis of those comments would be "success", and I doubt that could be construed as their intent.
  9. Platoon
    I have never understood th angst over the trade deadline decisions. Based on the Twins talent relative to their competitors, it was not just Falvines opinion that the Twins were not viable contenders, it was a widely held view. But the biggest issue here is the term "viable contenders". Ones interpretation of that term makes all the difference. but since hindsight is always best, let's move forward to early Oct. "17. Hindsight should show us that short of trading away the entire future, burning enormous amounts of cash, and somehow magically gettimg Verlander level FA and trades to come to MN as mostly rentals, nothing would have changed what was in reality a best case outcome to 2017. And since those fantasy baseball actions were not going to happen, I return to my original comment. Why the angst?
  10. Platoon
    I had sort of anticipated them blowing the whole lot of the pool money on a single pitching prospect, the best they could find. Maybe they tried that and could not find a suitable value? It just seems to me that the money had the most return in that manner, and admittedly the most risk. This isn't intended as a criticism, simply an uneducated observation.
  11. Platoon
    From the somewhat limited view in my recliner, I have no idea if he makes it back to the level of even an expensive long reliever. The surprise I am looking for is whether the new FO makes the decision based more on his usefulness to the roster, than his usefulness to the accounting department!
  12. Platoon
    I agree some of the comments have been purely racist. I never felt that my concerns were based on race. My concerns were based on level of play and in the two Twins, specifics. For Nishiokia, there really weren't any. I didn't see much video of him, plus I thought his position and skill set were more easily transferred to the level of MLB. Park was different. His video highlights showed him hitting bombs off of an endless variety of hanging spinners. Simple stats and math would tell us that there were going to be less of those at the MLB level than the KPL level. Such math applies to more than one Twin prospect who did the same in MiLB. As did the end, the same results. I go back to my long held belief that the Twins previous regime weighed publicity and marketing into the decision to sign Nishiokia and Park at a level that exceeded the players actual chance to succeed. It's either that, or at least in the case of Park they did not use the same criteria in evaluating his talents that they did whilst evaluating their own MiLB rosters.
  13. Platoon

    Radio matters

    Platoon commented on mikelink45's blog entry in mikelink45's Blog

    I really don't think with HD and the improvement in radios that the "static" is that harsh. And yes, XM does alleviate the issue for those who wish to subscribe. I did during the time I traveled the country. I loved it. But I also loved sitting on the bike in the parking lot of the Super 8 in Gillette Wyoming finishing a close game on 'CCO. And since it's the MINNESOTA Twins, not the Twin City Twins, statewide coverage is nice, for two reasons. It's not always easy to find the game when away from your local area. And in my area one of the stations that would take me west, skips a lot of games or innings for news and recipe shows. Lol
  14. Platoon
    Watching the Vikings is sort of like buying a lottery ticket. You know you won't win, but you buy one anyway, just in case you do. . While I don't think Kai F. could kick my dog, I think it will still be the QB who does them in. And it will be painful as usual. I cannot see Darvish coming to MN, regardless of whether JP opens his rusted vault doors, but I would not mind seeing the team "trade" some signing cash for some ready to use high end MiLB talent, that fits the teams timeline. The Twins are sitting in a good spot. One way or the other they should cash in on Ohtani. As for the football Rodents, I assume its safe to say you ain't in the boat "rowin"? I have no idea if Flexk can recruit the Gophers out of their 50 years of wandering in the desert? Even if he does, I cannot stand his coaching style. Less shouting and jumping up and down, and more thinking might help!
  15. Platoon
    I didn't mean that the chance wasn't worth taking per se. I meant that when the Twins win a bidding war it's time to look under the hood. There has to be something wrong. I don't intend that observation to be snarky at all, it's based on a long and easily verified history of their being well out of the running when making a run at quality talent.
  16. Platoon
    I will always wonder how much of this was marketing, both in Korea and in MN. The Twins had numerous bashers with long swings, who had trouble with both velocity and spin, and the inability to make contact. They put up good numbers in AAA and hardly ever set foot in MN. Yet we "outbid" all of baseball for Park, and were to believe his flaws were a mirage? I tend to be a skeptical pragmatic, and when the MN Twins, at least the previous administration, win a bidding contest at anything bigger than an estate auction, something is amiss.
  17. Platoon
    I think the number of Twins bunts is indicative of the managers seeming disregard for the inning, his starting pitcher, the opponent and at times the name of the bunter. Molitor often used small ball early in games, while wielding a fairly power laden team, with a very very average pitching staff. I know if I am the opposition, and you want to bunt away crooked number innings early in the game, just show me where you want that pitch layed in there. I will gladly give up that one run in the third inning.
  18. Platoon
    The obvious is that Sano is a large man, who isn't getting any smaller. Add to that some suspicion as to his work habits and his discipline. Everyone wants and hopes he stays at third, healthy and productive. And if he doesn't? What is plan B? That he will likely have an elite bat is not in question. But what will his mindset be if moved to 1B? Or worse, full time DH. While it may be totally acceptable to him, he didnt exactly embrace RF. Falvine and Molitor have far more insight than we do. But for me, any hint of recalcitrance over a position change,and I am looking for a nice return in the pitching market. His utmost value is as a third baseman, and I am not sure that's sustainable.
  19. Platoon
    If nothing else the last two years have confirmed what we all knew about Molitor. He is either a very very poor manager, or a very very good manager.
  20. Platoon
    This topic made me think of the Twins as a three legged stool, missing one leg. The pitching leg. You can keep adding to the other two legs all off season. But it's still gonna be missing that third leg come spring!
  21. Platoon
    I would assume I am not the only one surprised by these numbers. And he gives Mauer a few days off. Sort of like the Robbie G. situation, but with some power. Hits somewhat, but the glove work makes one squeamish. EE provides temporary protection for Sano, but I imagine next summer will be the decision year on Sano. On field player? DH? Or trade for pitching? I think the Twins offense is sufficient enough to start the season somewhat as is. I like Carlos Santana, but he is not money well spent for this team, nor is Frazier.
  22. Platoon
    Excellent take! Of course since it agrees with my thoughts from the deadline I would say that. Whether you use foresight or hindsight there is no doubt that the trades made, or not made were correct. Clamorimg for more C-level pitching help had to have been based on emotion. There was only one predicator that the team would improve second half. Strength of schedule, or shall we say lack thereof. And that does not make you a legitimate contender. Unless, as in the past, reaching the second WC was the epitome of orginisational desire. Hopefully those days are behind us.
  23. Platoon
    Your point is well made, and sad. I understand the use of, and somewhat obvious benefits of analytics. But that does not make the game more interesting. To me it makes it almost sterile!
  24. Platoon
    Like Spock, the posters you copied in your response do not have the ability to allow human emotions to enter into any equation! They operate on a cold, analytical, soulless, and pragmatic platform! :) Live Long and Prosper!
  25. Platoon
    The voters used a totally different criteria when voting for these two specific candidates. In Buxtons case it seems apparent that they used the actual definition of "Gold Glove". In Doziers they used "Gold Batting Glove". They have awards like AllPro for combined talent, which would have been available. I see Dozier thusly: solid reliable glove, average range, poor but accurate arm, with optical points awarded for diving endlessly and dirty jerseys. Mauer was the one dissed here. His seemingly effortless glove work, and ability to turn any throw within wingspan into an out was completely under appreciated.
×
×
  • Create New...