I guess that depends on your definition of consistently good. And I'd dispute the claim that the rotation played no role. In 2002 they gave up 26 runs in a five game series (their last postseason win) and 27 while losing in five. 2003: 16 runs in losing 3-1. You might make the claim here that the rotation wasn't a real concern. 2004: 21 runs in losing 3-1 (after posting a shutout in game 1). 2006: 16 runs in losing 3-0. 2009: 15 runs, lost 3-0. 2010: 17 runs, lost 3-0 The Twins gave postseason starts twice to Boof Bonser, Nick Blackburn, a one-armed Brad Radke, Carlos Silva, and twice to Brian Duensing, among others. There were consistent calls for the Twins to add a top line starter throughout that decade. So yeah, I think not adding through Free Agency likely hurt the Twins, and was a factor in their lack of post season success.