I couldn't disagree more. If you're out, you're out. Where do we stop with this? "He ALMOST beat the throw to first, he should be safe!" "He caught that liner on a short hop, call the guy out!" "Another foot and it would have been a home run! That's less than 0.33 percent of the distance required! Give it to him!" "Well yeah, hr rounded 3rd, and got tagged out, but he had already reached 3rd safely! He can't be out any more after that!" Think this through. It's...unworkable. You come off the bag, and get tagged, you're out.