my question was sincere. one magic formula says Bryant is the 20th best player and another magic formula says Bryant is the 55th best. that's a pretty big difference. if the discrepancy can't be explained beyond saying "they're different magic formulas," well, as the song goes: war -- what is it good for? and i think i know the answer. apparently, there is no explanation. war is a magic formula that we're just supposed to take at face value. and if one says what we want to hear, we should use that one and ignore the other one. pay no attention to the man behind the curtain ...