I think he means everyone gets the one in the rule book, not that a 5 foot player and a 7 foot player get the same zone.....I'd bet good money on that being his intent.
Ya, I think you are finding all the edge cases here to argue "you can't make it 100% perfect, so don't improve it at all".....at least that is how it reads.
There is noise in the math that runs computers, is used to assess outcomes in business processes, in every measurement, there is noise. Denying that something is real because there are multiple variables and noise.....that's not going to lead to good outcomes in any line of business. I don't think that's what he's saying, but is sounds like that is what he is saying....
There is zero evidence that rule is real. The links studying the actual effect and debunking it as not true at all are all over if you want to find them.
He clearly has a shot. If the O's somehow make the playoffs and Machado carries them, it could be him. Really, it depends on what the Jays, O's and Angels do as teams the rest of the way. Trout will still be hurt by old schoolers, Donaldson by Canada and all the hitters they've amassed....imo.
Then bench him to playing around 40 games a year. I can't think of any off the top of my head, I know guys get injured, and 1 guy retired a couple years ago, but I'd bet it is rare. Doesn't make it right, btw......just, as you say, reality.
Smart organizations figured out sunk costs in the 1980s, literally......if not sooner. Hunter and Mauer are sunk costs, that absolutely should be cut/benched (more so Mauer). It just is what it is. Winning brings fans, are you suggesting this market wouldn't love Buxton like they loved Kirby, Denard, Torii eventually?
This whole "he has to go to AAA to face harder pitching" thing cracks me up. when I push to have guys go to AAA, like Kepler or Buxton earlier, I am told that it doesn't matter, there isn't much difference in the pitching, or "you can jump right from AA to the majors"........now I am told that Buxton has to go to AAA because the pitching is better and you really should go to every level first.....I am confused since many of these people are the same people making two different arguments.