Twins got a B in 2008, more teams had better grades than had worse grades. Twins got a B in 2007, more teams got worse grades than got better grades (that year looks really bad on BA) Twins got a C in 2006, not good compared to most teams, only three had worse grades Twins got an A in 2005, tied with 7 other teams for the best grade. Looked very good according to BA at the time. I'm not sure how that is "good" or "bad" at drafting. One good year, one bad year, and two mediocre years. About median compared to other grades, according to BA. That's fine, I guess. Nothing to brag about, imo. YMMV, of course. But if you won't sign big time free agents, you have to be better at drafting than other teams, not about the same. One interesting (to me) thing to see, several teams were consistently rated the worst, and not coincidentally they are now some of the worst teams in baseball.