Again, you're arguing how much his hits count. Everyone else is arguing that his value as a hitter is higher (and much, much higher) as a catcher than as a 1B or DH. And again, there isn't any disputing this, as it's based on math. If you don't agree with WAR, or the math behind it, that's fine. But a good-hitting catcher is worth way more to a team than a good-hitting first baseman. Why? because you can find a decent 1B a lot of other places, while most other catchers are complete garbage on offense.