Except there is no way that your average rural American likes Donald Trump the person. At least, I have to believe that or we are truly doomed. I don't think it is about the person OR the platform, so much as the message. The Democrats have completely abandoned their base. LGBT rights are extremely important, but that isn't the base. Protecting minorities and Muslims is important, and necessary. But again, not the base. The base of the DFL has always been the white working class. I reluctantly voted for Hillary. Donald was never an option for me. He crossed lines, that to me could never be overlooked. But, I live in rural America, and I know several people who voted for Trump. Only one of these people, and I know most of them quite well, would I consider to be a racist, or sexist, or xenophobe. My brother voted for Trump, and he is one of the most compassionate, respectful, open minded people I've ever known. His reason was the inverse of mine. Hillary was simply not an option to him, so he held his nose and voted for Trump. I agree with you that this election was not winnable for Hillary, but I don't agree that it was unwinnable for the Dems. Trump tapped into a sector of the country that has felt ignored, condescended, and looked down upon for quite a while now. People will follow almost anyone if they feel it's their only hope. Those on the left (not you Levi) who want to insist that close to half the country is racist, sexist, xenophobic, whatever, and that is why Trump was elected need to wake up. I'm not saying anyone here feels that way, but some might, and in reading and watching the news outlets, most of those same out of touch elites still are. If they go down that path, we might never recover from this. Talking down to people, judging people, generalizing people, all that does is further galvanize them in their F you stance. The good news for Dems is that if us, and the planet can survive these next four years, then they have a chance to come out of this stronger than ever. But if that is to happen, they need to completely change the way the party as a whole, and people associated with the party (Hollywood, msnbc, huff post, etc.) treat, and speak of this sector of people. When a white, working class American turns on cable news, they don't see any representation of them. None, ever. Not even a squeak. When they read an article on buzzfeed, or HuffPost, or Slate, or name your favorite liberal newsfeed, they don't read anything speaking for them. Every article or story is BLM, or trans rights, or immigration issues, or the war on women. And I believe that this sector of people are sympathetic to those causes. But they also think they face problems too, can't one or two articles speak for them occasionally? Trump is an awful human, even those I spoke to who voted for him think as much. But he made these people feel like he is on their side, like he has their back. And, that is a powerful feeling. We all know it's BS, he isn't capable of having anyone's back but his own. But it's hard to see that when you feel ignored, and looked down on by half the country. Many people will say that it was selfish and short sighted to vote for Trump. That, I can agree with. I even told my brother, if this man leads this country into a dark place - nuclear war, irreversible climate damage, rounding up of Mexican immigrants, reversal of LGBT rights, violent or oppressive treatment of Muslims, a war on women, anything like that- then he's going to have blood on his hands. Nobody will be able to say they didn't see it coming. My brother says he rolled the dice that his words are just campaign bluster and negotiating tactics. But if he's wrong, after the things Trump has said and done, there is literally no place that Trump can lead us that his supporters can claim couldn't have been predicted. That accountability, I think is fair. Judging, and insulting the half of Americans who voted for him, that is not fair, or at least is not helpful. Sorry for the long post, I've read every word in this thread over the last 4 days. It's taken me 13 hours to do so and I've observed a lot throughout the thread. I thought it was great. A lot of logical, intelligent, almost entirely civil debate. Thank you all for that. Oh, and finally, Levi you crushed this thread. That is why I quoted you. Not just on your foresight of the issues that kept Trump in, and ultimately delivered him the win, but also on the other subtopics as well. Particularly gun control. Well done sir!