Really? Hughes' numbers starting the past two seasons: 2016: 11 starts, 5.97 ERA, hitters hit .846 OPS, 5.0 K/9 2017: 9 starts, 5.74 ERA, hitters hit .875 OPS, 5.7 K/9 And he's coming off of another round of surgery... I just can't see how he could be "impactful" in the rotation. Compare that to Mejia and May: Mejia 2017: 21 starts, 4.50 ERA, hitters hit .822 OPS, 7.8 K/9 May 2015: 15 starts, 4.37 ERA, hitters hit .753 OPS, 7.95 K/9 It's hard to speculate if May could be the same in the rotation, but I think Mejia will improve off of his 2017 numbers, so I just can't see how Hughes will be better than both of them. IMO Phil looks like he's nearing the end of the line.