Crucial Situations from The Hardball Times In any given inning, the 4th hitter will have the most opportunities to drive in a runner. Because if he reaches the plate then there is at least 1 runner on base, by definition. In a 1 run game, you play to the 4th hitter (Markakis in this case). And that's exactly what Gardy did. Reimold got his leadoff single, then Gardy got Robertson warming up immediately. He simply passed on Perkins in favor of Robertson. Because you haven't played the 9th inning yet. You don't know that you won't score again in the top of the 9th. You don't know that you'll give up 2 cheap groundball singles again in the home half. The only think you know is that the first runner is on in a 5-4 game in the home 8th, with a very good lefthanded hitter batting 4th. The reason Gardy opted for Robertson instead of Perkins, I suspect, is because he expected the leadoff man man to sac bunt at that point. To play for the tie, basically, and try again in the bottom of the 9th. Because that's what he would have done. Instead, Buck let Machado swing away and by the time Markakis stepped up there were runners on 2nd and 3rd with 1st base open. For the record, the O's had so many things go right that inning that its hard for me to take it out on Gardy. And even so, as others have said, if Robertson can't get one lefthander out, then what is he on the team for? More than anything, I would blame the loss on the GM for leaving Gardy 1 very goo... rock soli... pretty goo... one passable MLB lefthander short to start the year.