I agree that keeping May up is the most important thing right now. I get that you ride the hot hand with Pelfrey, but given his history, it's probably a mirage. May certainly has better upside. In fact, according to BR: Trevor May: ERA - 4.43 / FIP - 2.60 Mike Peflrey: ERA - 2.25 / FIP - 4.53 May's differential is 1.83 in the right direction. Pelfrey's differential is 2.23 in the wrong direction.