I’m sorry but I don’t agree with any of this.
He was not the main reason for the early collapse of anywhere close to it. The Twins faltered early on because of two things:
1. Colome blowing saves and the rest of the pitching staff sucking
2. Simmons giving the team COVID
Neither of those two things are Baldelli’s fault. The FO is the one who signed Colome and designated him as their closer. Baldelli wasn’t the one who made that decision. If you want to argue he ruined Colome, how much do you think Baldelli actually coaches his pitchers? If he did it to any significant degree, they probably wouldn’t have a designated pitching coach. If you think they ruined Colome, it’s not Baldelli’s fault. Stuck with Colome too long? He only stuck with him for 5 blown saves, y’all act like it’s 15 or 20.
As for the pitching staff, I don’t think you understand the true ****tieness of the hand dealt to him. He was handed a rotation featuring JA Happ and Matt Shoemaker for 40% of the starts. Both aging #5-at-best starters at the time. The Twins didn’t “ruin” Happ and Shoemaker, they were simply bad pitchers.
As for the bullpen he was dealt, you can say the same thing about Duffey at times, Rogers at times, Thielbar at times, etc. that I said about Colome. That’s on the pitching coach, not Baldelli.
Also, Simmons. Not only did he post a -0.5 WAR on the season, but he also came to camp unvaccinated and he was the first one to catch COVID. That derailed the team quite a bit.
Saying that he’s only good at giving interviews and nothing else is pretty unfair. Have you ever considered he played the game himself and was a very fundamentally sound player? We have seen problems with the fundamentals throughout the year, but that is attributed to a coaching staff as a whole, not just a manager. And I don’t think that Baldelli would have much to do with problems with the fundamentals, because that’s something he demonstrated he can do well.