His batting average on balls in play in AAA has been very high. 2015: 59 plate appearances, .500 BABIP 2016 (first stint): 129 PA, .393 BABIP 2016 (second stint): 64 PA, .419 BABIP I imagine International League average BABIP (not sure where to look that up and verify) is more like the American League's .300. A very few hitters can sustain it consistently above that, but not many. And Buxton's BABIP, if not a mirage, hasn't translated to the majors yet. I too would like to see him play in AAA a while longer - see how he does when the ball isn't falling in quite as handily, OR see if the major league numbers come to look more like the aberration.