Well yes, because your "time and again"s are limited to years 2011-13 when the team was on the way to a putrid record by the time these moves were made. What would be the equivalent moves in 2010 when they were on the way to a division title? (I'm serious, I don't know at the moment how to look up a season's transactions, and maybe he did shed payroll in July.) Is it really wrong to say in July-August that we're not winning so what's the point of spending $X for the rest of the season? And does it apply as a forecast of future actions in seasons that aren't like that? / edit - heh, Pilgrim and I reacted pretty much to the same thing