tony&rodney

Brooks Lee is not indispensable or essential to the Twins. Carlos Correa is the key. While it is preferable by me and many others for Brooks Lee to be available to play successfully for the Twins, the team has other players on the roster and in the minor leagues whose talents are not horrible far from what Lee has provided thus far. Every MLB team has injuries and need to fill those lost IL roster spots. When i look over the list of players who will miss several weeks or longer across baseball it seems like the Twins are in a decent spot right now. If Correa, Buxton, Lopez, and Ryan go down the Twins will have some concerns to iron out. Let's hope the injuries stay minor and not get too worried in late March.

I'm not picking on your thoughts or arguments, but merely responding to the specific sentence I quoted. Never a good idea to make vast assumptions. You may be correct but there may be more than a few experts that read Twins Daily. FWIW, I'm not an expert. Sport specific weight training has been around for much more than a quarter century for every sport and for both genders. I can't believe people have such strong opinions on this topic. The steroid era was created and promoted by media, management, and money and many players went along for the ride because they have short careers to make their cash and it was legal. In baseball it is called The Selig Era. Injuries happen .... they always did. Many more players were injured in my high school years in the 60s/70s than were ever injured during my decades of coaching. I credit the dedicated sports training personnel for their work. While I myself and many of my peers were abused in the name of toughness or "be a man", I can proudly say I never abused an athlete or put winning above an individual's health. The trainers today are incredible well educated / outstanding and athletes prepare in ways they feel will be conducive to performance. Some players may over prepare, if that is a thing, but I believe it is done in an honest effort to be their best selves. Maybe a little empathy is all that we should have for an injured player instead of looking for blame. It's a bumper sticker: Sh*t Happens.

Winokur made the 6-3 DP look as easy as anyone could. He is quick.

Impressively did not swing at a slider just off the plate. Solid line drive. Spring Training - where two batters wear the same uniform number on first and third (#11 - Winokur & Gasper). Funny stuff.

Hard to know if Lee will be on IL at this time. To your request, I would definitely keep Julien and Martin among the four players in the interest of winning games. Others will totally disagree with me and you should expect a wide number of choices between those four players.

This is fair. We should all be aware that Max Kepler gave a number of people on TD some serious cases of alarm (baseball ptsd), but Kepler was an excellent regular. If Jenkins is Kepler, that's ok. Maybe he can even be better. Prospects are of interest to a number of baseball fans. I'm a guy who follows prospects and minor league baseball. The rankings are just for fun. I don't see them as a religion. If people are not interested in the rankings or prospects they should skip those articles and posts to avoid irritation.

Winokur in lineup.

Well put. The front office has FOMO when it comes to looking at their players. I thought Julien and even Lewis would have brought back some decent possibilities after the 2023 season. My first thought when the 2024 season ended was to trade Lee for a catcher. At this point all of Lewis, Lee, and Julien seem like keys to the 2025 season, although I don't see any of them around by 2027. The general belief in Lewis as a core player for the Twins is totally fair but I just don't see it.

It would be a surprising move if the Twins suddenly began to play Keirsey Jr., one that might prove useful. Still seems very unlikely. I thought the Twins should have traded Julien after the 2023 season. He is awkward defensively and whenever the bat tilts too steep his plate appearances suffer. The Twins simply do not have good defenders right now for second base. Gasper is stationary but people love him; mustache. Lee has a bad back but is too slow for the position. Castro is erratic and gets poor reads on ground balls. I thought we might see Martin at second, the Twins don't even give him repetitions. That leaves Eddie, who is the worst fielder but has the best range of the bunch (note - Julien does not have good range). Given the recent injuries, i would like to see a Buck, Julien, Correa, Larnach, Miranda, Wallner, France, Jeffers, Castro lineup versus Sonny Gray.

The calls for Keirsey Jr. are almost sure to be in vain. Brooks Lee will need to show that his back is fine or he opens on the IL. Gasper is the latest darling. He can hit and makes the plays if the ball is right to him. The pitcher's union wants him to DH only. Martin looks like he will open in St. Paul. Julien is the 2B. Lastly, the Twins are always up for surprises, meaning we are all just guessing.

Is this article as close as TD comes to telling the readers that the season may depend on 2023 Julien?

The Twins are built on offense. They need to air it out in order to win. Fangraphs had a funny about the Twins, "... defense is an elective course rather than a part of the core curriculum at the Minnesota Finishing School for Humongous Left-Handed Corner Sluggers."

As the wonderful Anduhar once said, "the one thing you can be sure of is you never know." FWIW, ownership has absolutely no input in the roster. If you are referring to payroll, remember that the Twins have the highest payroll in their division and have spent more money than their competitors since Falvey arrived. Keep your head up.

Worth noting that Fangraphs believes Jenkins will be a middle of the order bat and "impact regular". They are not high on his arm and thus see him in left field. We will know much more about Jenkins by September. There isn't any reason to worry.

Top 20 is still pretty high and supposes some good outcomes. The back half of top 100 lists see a fair amount of deviation in results but the top guys usually have serious talent.

The loss of Gimenez may hurt at second base and the starting rotation seems to have questions. However, there is a fair amount of talent on the roster. The younger players could take major steps forward this season, even with DeLauter out for 12+ weeks. While it may be difficult to project any of the AL Central teams, Cleveland nearly always plays fundamental baseball and despite the thoughts from some folks that these don't amount to much it makes sense to me that Cleveland is the favorite to win the division in some quarters.

Jhoan Duran is a really good valuable late inning relief pitcher. Really believed that Duran could have been packaged with one or two others to bring back a noteworthy player. Apparently I was wrong.

I guess I have to know how many times you have seen either Walker Jenkins or Emmanuel Rodriguez play. What specifically did you SEE across a minimum of 2 dozen games that makes you "lower" on those two? I'm curious. Naturally I have my own thoughts on players too but I want to know what you have seen.

The entire line about a lack of financial commitment/ spending is confusing to me. A large number of comments have included versions of this in their thoughts. Who was going to be added the last two years? A large chorus of people called for the Twins to sign Jordan Montgomery and Rhys Hoskins for the 2024 team. What were the targets this past winter? From my couch it seems like the Twins front office put together exactly the roster they desired for this coming season. It may not have been what I desired but Falvey gets what Falvey wants. The Twins added Coulombe, Bader, France, and Gasper. They also decided to hold Paddack, Castro, Vazquez, and the rest. Next week we shall see how the team begins their campaign and how the Twins plan unfolds. That is about our only choice. Go Twins.

Personally, I had poor luck when I attended Twins games last season. It wasn't the wins and losses. It was the slow plodding on the bases mixed in with outfielders missing the cutoff man, throwing the ball to the wrong base, and heaving throws to the backstop when the opposing runner just cruised across home plate. The infielders were pretty good on balls hit directly at them but struggled going in directions. When October arrived, I was aware that several Twins had seen their value drop due to less than stellar results, but it seemed like the front office would be proactive in the trade market. I was prepared for a roster budget of $100-120 million and believed anything higher than that would be bonus cash. The payroll limit was a total nonissue for me. Looking around the league it felt there were opportunities for some change, specifically to upgrade the defensive talent and roster players who could run a little bit. Turns out that wasn't the plan. I was wrong - dead wrong. As a Twins fan this is a time to reset and recover. It is time to swallow whatever hopes loomed during the offseason and accept the present roster, to cough up some optimism for the campaign ahead. I'm hoping Carlos Correa and Byron Buxton have their best years yet and hoping that some other players emerge as complimentary pieces to support them. I'm hopeful the Twins pitchers stay healthy and productive and focus on what they can do and not to worry about those events out of their control, like the issues of other's gloves. I'm hopeful the Twins uncover playing time for a couple of young talented players and win the division. The Twins are going to win the World Series.

No comparison between these two guys. Castino was Lewis-like athletic with a lithe body. He hit triples, could run, and his defense was on a different level than Lee. Castino did have to retire due to back issues and had to have his spine fused. Castino moved on to a regular life outside of baseball. The extent of Lee's back problems have not entered the serious zone yet.

Sure seems like a pile of guys all qualified to be a DH. Brooks Lee does ok at shortstop, he has always projected at third base, but is a little short on range for second base. Willi Castro is pretty much strictly a utility player. He has played often this March and his swing looks weak. The gloves are a problem and that was before Lewis went down. The Twins are going to play the guys who hit. That's the way they roll. My stress is low about who plays where because I cannot see a difference and neither can the Twins. If they could, the decisions would have already been stated.

Softball.

Feels like more than a thumbs up is needed to your response. I agree with you wholeheartedly and I didn't necessarily need all of the supportive data to place Brad Radke as among the all time great Twins pitchers. In fairness I have followed and examined WAR from the start. I'm not sure what people missed or why Radke did not get the respect he deserved. He got (gets) it from me. I appreciate you putting the numbers forth to shine the light on Brad Radke.

Starting pitchers work forward on their pitch counts beginning at an inning or around 20 pitches. The progression then goes more or less forward by 15-20 pitches. Pablo Lopez indicated in an interview during the game that he was working on a couple of things and wanted to push past the scheduled pitch mark. Lopez is an experienced pitcher and Baldelli will pull him at points where he is off and ineffective during the season but the pitch count this week simply reflects what Lopez was working towards. I wouldn't say this is too unusual or noteworthy. Skenes was up to 85 pitches yesterday in his last start before Opening Day as well.