tony&rodney
Old-Timey Member-
Posts
10,778 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
94
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by tony&rodney
-
I'm not sure how Zoll would view this. FYI, it looks like Henderson has two years. $14M this year and then ..... ?
-
If you felt I was dismissive I'm sorry. There was no intent. My short response was not very good because it was incomplete and easily taken wrong. That was entirely my fault. I'm sorry for my clumsiness. The publication today, just like all of the television ads by MLB, was intended to gain public support against the PA. It was not a serious offer. The issues remain the same. MLB, unlike all of the other sport leagues, has private books and is unwilling to be transparent. A cap doesn't work unless it is tied specifically to revenue numbers that can be independently verified. The MLBPA has gone through great struggles to gain their position. They are unlikely to abandon it. The kicker is that the owners have said they will lock the players out until they get what they want, a cap system. However, the media deals have a clause that requires an additional year if there are 60 games missed. At that point the owners are boxed in. If there is a long lockout everyone loses .... a lot, nobody more so than the owners. The owners need to decide how to redistribute all revenues in a manner the team owners can accept. When they have a plan, they can sit down and negotiate a deal with the PA that is useful for everyone. It really isn't a solid strategy to play out negotiations publically. Us fans can discuss this and have sides but the leaking of details and public announcements only serves to reduce any prior trust. What are your views on this topic?
- 19 replies
-
- carlos correa
- sonny gray
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Yes, true, but it is a fake offer to push the cap system. The deadline of missing 60 games still holds and the owners are the ones who need to find an agreement in time that the union accepts or their screwed. At that point everyone will lose.
- 19 replies
-
- carlos correa
- sonny gray
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Mayo holds no interest for me but Westburg was a decent player before the injury. The Twins are pretty set at 2B, 3B, SS unless they go big and gamble on signing a slugger like Brandon Lowe. Not sure we match up with the Orioles.
-
I like that you kept the payroll down. I didn't but I would be surprised if the Twins opened 2027 above $135M. Interesting that roll it back mostly but also keep Abel and Rojas in AAA (guess). Hands. Luke was moved because of his hands, so first base doesn't work. He is a work in progress in RF, where he was placed because it is the smallest space in Target Field and more balls are hit to the other fields. He was almost average in September. My guess is he remains in RF.
-
I can't find your blueprint. Is it up?
- 44 replies
-
- royce lewis
- trevor larnach
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
The media deals are put off one year if 60 games are missed, which will cost the owners a ton of moola. Expect a new CBA in April at the latest because ST still needs to happen.
- 19 replies
-
- carlos correa
- sonny gray
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
That makes sense. How would you accomplish this? Did you submit a 2027 Roster Blueprint?
- 44 replies
-
- royce lewis
- trevor larnach
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Riverbrian’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint:
tony&rodney replied to Riverbrian's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Can only tell you - the Twins tried everything. -
Agree the Twins are willing to take that gamble. Jeffers accepting puts the current roster well over the number used in the Blueprint. That means no additions. As far as losing draft choices .... that seems like the cost of failing to trade Joe Ryan for the rumored deal to the Red Sox and holding guys like Larnach, Wallner, Lewis, and Jeffers instead of trading them. Relief pitchers are notoriously variable but the best are pretty solid. Bednar and Morejon have been reliable, which is no guarantee for the future. The Twins made some choices and will need to be very proactive to reach 81 wins again. Free agents do not cost players within the current system. Losing the third and fourth picks is a tough outcome but rolling into 2027 with no additions would make winning 76 games again a tough battle. I think the Twins need to sign one top bullpen pitcher. Either that or as a few people have advocated the club needs to look to 2028 and 2029.
-
Riverbrian’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint:
tony&rodney replied to Riverbrian's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Thank you for the response. I appreciate it. Agree that none of us has an idea about trades but the nature of the site is purely speculative so it can be worth guesses. I get you are not comfortable doing that though and respect it. You did put out specific names. I'm not ever serious about mine but rather just throwing out ideas. Wallner? I think that decision was already made. A note on Wallner that might matter - he cannot hit any fastball at or above 95MPH. I do wish Wallner had been given a chance from the beginning to be only a DH. I'm not sure if that would have made any difference. Lewis? I have no idea what to do with Lewis. I advocated for trading him in November of 2023 and the reaction was ..... ? (visceral). The mantra of earning it makes sense but when a team spends money it always seems like they stick with it too long. Mainly I am really concerned that Zoll & TP just roll it back again because that is the past practice. Impossible to guess the budget too. These blueprints were supposed to (imo) be a way for people to put out their rosters, defend their choices, and create conversations. After little participation in the last two years and mostly not useful comments, there are some better responses this year, but less than 20 people have put forth their rosters including many of the folks who are often very critical of others. I'm not sure why there is so little participation. Maybe the Blueprint needs to be in its own thread under Forums as opposed to just the last comment. Perhaps people don't know to go to place where the blueprints are found. -
Riverbrian’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint:
tony&rodney replied to Riverbrian's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
MLR? Did you post your roster? -
This is (mol) what I have thought. There are ideas brought up in the comments. 1. Would the Twins spend the $23M elsewhere? There is no indication of a budget and the club has no obligation to hint at one. Most people would suggest that a 25% increase in budget is a significant number. A $130M payroll would be a big increase. Of course, everyone will scream $160M from several years back. I get it. There is hope that the Twins go to $160M but what are the odds. Is that realistic? Brock set the number at $135M and it seems like everyone is going over. Sadly few people have submitted. 2. A number of people have suggested Jeffers is the best catcher available. I think this needs clarity. He is the best slugging catcher available. There are a number of better catchers available. This pushes forward whether defense is that important. Call Cleveland or Milwaukee for your answer, which many people do reject. 3. Jeffers caught 80 games last year. 88 games at catcher is his career high. How much is that worth? Go back to the budget. If it is less than $160M the Twins cannot afford to roster a part time player at $23M. Jeffers is a good player and one who can contribute but cost versus budget should be a realistic part of the discussion as should the importance of defense. Does anyone have any feel at all for where the budget will settle?
-
Luis Arraez is a really fun plate appearance to watch. Actually, Jake Bauers had several "Arraez" displays during the playoffs. Of course, power is the difference. I'm not sure what Bauers will do in 2027 but just about everyone is expecting him to take the qualifying offer. Luis can be counted on to score about 60-70 runs per year and he might knock in the same amount if he he stays healthy. . Health, especially the legs, is a big concern. The fielding metrics were happier with Arraez than they ever were in the past. How much credibility does one place on that sudden dramatic change. Arraez has below average speed. Why does anyone believe the Twins would get more production from Arraez than Kody Clemens? FWIW, I want Clemens in a utility role.
- 44 replies
-
- royce lewis
- trevor larnach
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Riverbrian’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint:
tony&rodney replied to Riverbrian's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Good roster and it looks fairly realistic to me. Thank you for submitting one. I count only 14 submitted rosters with many, many frequent TD voices absent. Thus, pleased to see you put up one The idea of Sato is fun and I think Morejon is a good idea. I'm interested in how you acquired Schmitt, Estrada, and Bachman. They are all good acquisitions but the price for them is unclear to me. Did you trade Abel, Rojas, Matthews for them? Finally, what do you see in Wallner? He was a darling for almost everyone on Twins Daily before last year but his fans have abandoned him. Wallner is a pure DH and you state that you would not use a DH, so I was merely curious. -
Seems like the decision that Twins Daily desired. "Minnesota hasn't extended a qualifying offer to one of its players since Sonny Gray following the 2023 season. Gray declined that offer before signing with St. Louis, and the Twins eventually used their compensatory selection to draft infielder Kyle DeBarge. Now, Minnesota is hoping for a similar outcome with Jeffers." That last sentence is rough. Hoping for another DeBarge is lost money. Yet, I hope the Twins get the pick. They can only do better.
-
MeleMouth’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint: MeleMouth Blueprint
tony&rodney replied to MeleMouth's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Interesting to read your thought process and see your choices. That is a young rotation. I'm guessing Ryan is traded for prospects a ways off. It seems unusual to move a starting pitcher returning from injury to the bullpen but it could work. One detail I have noticed from several rosters is the movement of Luke Keaschall to DH and a few people have him in left field. Left field is more difficult and larger at Target Field, which is why the move from 2B to Rf was made last season. Of course, the Twins could move him again. DH is a very difficult position for an athletic young player. While I think every outfielder will be used as a DH at some point, I'm not seeing Keaschall as a DH more than once per week. -
Jeffers was given the QO by the Twins
tony&rodney replied to Cory Engelhardt's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Well, I was wrong. I didn't think the Twins wanted to take a chance on paying a half time position player for $23M. The Twins made an interesting choice but they certainly have information and we do not. -
Good thoughts. I'm interested to see your roster blueprint.
- 44 replies
-
- royce lewis
- trevor larnach
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
bjorks’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint: Unrealistic
tony&rodney replied to bjorks's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Couple of fyi notes. Pivetta has been injured which is why Padres declined his option. They want to sign him for less. Marte is signed through 2031. The next three years at $20M, $22M, and $22M before a player option for $11.5 M in 2031. -
Looks pretty solid. The bet for the bullpen is that Abreu and Vesia provide more than one big signing (Bednar, Morejon) I guess and that makes sense. One wonders if Marte would agree to be traded or if Zoll (the Twins brain trust) has interest. Marte can be very good, but he also has a big contract, especially in 2028-2030. I am curious why you chose Stephenson over Kelly at catcher.

