While I don't disagree with this point when speaking in generalities, 2015 Trevor May is, at worst, a similar pitcher to 2015 James Shields. He's probably a touch better but I'll defer to Shields' ability to eat innings and call it a wash. Tyler Duffey, while SSS abounds, has been better than both. And Jose Berrios is more talented than either May or Duffey. So, yeah... I just can't see what Shields brings to the table here. James Shields of 3-4 years ago, yeah. He was a very good pitcher but we're talking about 2016 James Shields, not 2012 James Shields. I don't want 2016 James Shields that much and I want absolutely nothing to do with 2018 James Shields. The Twins need to focus on removing expiring contracts, not trade them away for even longer contracts to the likes of Reyes or Shields.