We have no idea what Ryan actually said in that interview. The only word in quotation was "thin", which was made in reference to elite pitching. To make any assertion about JR's beliefs requires several turns at the Jump To Conclusions mat. Gibson made two starts in AAA. Two. He jumped from GCL to Fort Myers to Rochester after only a handful of starts. I put absolutely zero stock in that performance, as he was still in the rehab stage. A full offseason and Spring Training will show what he's capable of doing, not ~10 rehab starts in the minors. Look at that first slash stat of McCarty's line. Yeah, that batting average of nearly .400 was sustainable, especially considering that it was a full .101 higher than anything he had previously posted during any significant stretch of MiLB hitting. He also did it over a measly 175 PAs in the hitter-happy-haven PCL (remember those days?). To top that off, McCarty went and posted six consecutive sub-.700 OPS seasons in the major leagues. Parmelee, on the other hand, posted a 1.100 OPS in September last year and is posting a .919 OPS this September. In the last 14 months, if Parmelee plays, he hits. That's all there is to it. Despite his inconsistent play and general jerking around by the front office and Gardy, he has still managed a career OPS over .800 in ~250 PAs. And while people tend to discount his MiLB numbers, they were remarkably solid. He posted an OPS of .800 or better in every season except two, his first full season in Beloit (which he followed with a .881 OPS the next season) and one in New Britain. He's been a very consistent hitter who never garnered much attention because of his lack of power (which is no longer a problem) and his position, first base. In short, the McCarty comp carries no weight. And there's no reason to think that neither Hicks nor Arcia will receive anything more than a September call-up in 2013. Both should start the season in AAA and if one of them is tearing the cover off the ball, we'll see him before the All-Star break.