Reflections on Joe Mauer's Hall of Fame Career, From Those Who Grew Up With It

[Theodore Tollefson]

Joe Mauer is officially a member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame. It's a triumphant moment for many Minnesotans, but for those who were kids as the prime of his career played out, it holds a special significance.

Image courtesy of Dan Tollefson

Joe Mauer has been many things, to many people, at many times. He was a three-sport high-school superstar, the number-one overall pick in the 2001 MLB draft, and the best catching prospect in all of baseball. He made his MLB debut on April 5, 2004, and went 2-for-3 with two singles, two walks, and the game-winning run scored via a Shannon Stewart walk-off homer.

On that day, a title was thrust upon him that he was never able to shake--for all the right reasons. He became the hometown hero not only for the kids of the Twin Cities and surrounding suburbs, but for all of Minnesota. 

From there, Mauer went on to become an All-Star, three-time batting champion, Silver Slugger and Gold Glove winner, and MVP. It’s those accolades, his character, and the way he went about treating the fans (especially the kids admiring him) that have earned him the call to Cooperstown.

Five-plus years have passed since Mauer’s retirement, and those who were kids for the majority of his career have entered adulthood. While time has changed many things, it hasn’t changed the perception these kids had of Mauer when they were young.

“Joe gave every kid growing up someone to idolize,” said Sam Pahl, who graduated from Burnsville High School in 2017. “His induction to the Hall of Fame puts a bow on his prolific career while giving us kids growing up one last fond memory of our hometown hero.”

Mauer quickly became a role model for many Minnesotan kids. Whether it be doing commercials with his mother as his dinner date, destroying prized possessions with Joe Nathan in the basement, or public appearances throughout the Twin Cities at charity events, hospital visits, or even Winter Caravan stops, Mauer found ways to connect with the community beyond the diamond. 

While individual interactions Mauer had with kids were limited by his schedule, those five minutes he gave every kid could mean the world to them. Meeting a hero who lived up to expectations is rare, but Mauer was that rare exception for so many kids in the state. The man they saw on TV ads and behind the plate almost every day for the Twins showed himself to be the exceptional human being kids' imaginations made him out to be.

“Joe represented my pride in the Twins and in Minnesota,” said 2018 Wayzata High School graduate and fellow Twins Daily contributor, Nash Walker. “A hometown hero who never left our state means everything as a fan.”

“Most kids grow up at a young age wanting to be like Spiderman or whoever their favorite superhero is,” said Jacob Becker, a fellow Burnsville High School graduate from 2017. “But I wanted to be like Joe Mauer. I had a poster [of Mauer] in my room that said ‘Fast, Fearless, Strong, and Tobacco Free!’ I looked at the poster every day and it served its purpose as I grew up.” 

The icon on countless kids posters across Minnesota bedrooms was a common sight from 2006-2013. As many of these kids came of age playing Little League, Mauer’s batting stance was commonly emulated at the plate (as best they could), even if they couldn’t hit the ball the other way.

“Joe Mauer was everyone’s favorite player in elementary school,” said Blake Andert, another Burnsville High School grad from 2017. “Whenever we played baseball at recess, it was always a competition to decide who got to pretend to be Mauer and then Justin Morneau.”

“Mauer inspired me to play baseball growing up and made me believe a guy from the Twin Cities could be an all-star,” Zach McGovern, another Burnsville alumnus, said. “He was an inspiration on and off the field.” 

Efforts to emulate his smooth swing and a desire to play catcher hit almost every Minnesota kid as their baseball career progressed (or ended) in those years. Even for the kids who were able to make it to their high-school teams, Mauer’s career wasn’t the same at first base. The memory of who he was in his prime was still a massive influence at these kids' points in life.

“Joe Mauer was the reason I started batting left-handed when I was eight years old,” said Michael Michelizzi, a 2017 Proctor High School graduate. “I was so upset when he moved to first base, because it felt like such a changing of the guard. Seeing him put the catcher gear back on one final time brought a tear to my eye.”  

“Not only is it incredibly rare to have one player with one team, let alone his hometown team,” said Hunter Pinke, a 2016 Hastings High School graduate. “Because of that, every Minnesotan has a Joe Mauer story. For us, playing ball in Hastings stories were always told that there was only one player in Hastings who ever stole a base off Mauer. He was that special." 

Hastings High School was and remains in the same Minnesota State High School League conference as Cretin-Derham Hall. 

Mauer even introduced many of the more, ah, suburban Twin Cities kids to hip-hop. From 2006 onward, not an at-bat went by at either the Metrodome or Target Field where Mauer’s walk-up song wasn’t T.I.’s ‘What You Know’. If it wasn’t a genre your parents would let you listen to, Mauer’s walk-up song would be one place to start finding out more. 

Now, the moment of fulfillment has arrived. All these kids of Mauer’s career are adults, and they get to see their childhood icon get waved into Baseball immortality. 

"He's my childhood hero, just like any young baseball player in Minnesota," said Alex Cotter, a 2017 Lakeville South graduate. "Although the stats and accolades on the field are what you'll always see next to his name, what he's done for Twins Territory and what he's meant to his home state. That alone is enough for him to be in the Hall of Fame."

“It’s rare for a player to spend their whole career with one team and play there at such a high level,” said Blake Mattson, a 2017 Andover High School graduate. “It felt special to have Joe Mauer, a player who grew up in Minnesota, play for the Twins for so many years with so much success. It’s an honor to see him get inducted.”

Then, there’s my own experience, mixed in with friends (old and new) who grew up with Mauer as their icon. The first time I met him was a quick in-line autograph at Twins Fest 2009. It took almost two hours of waiting, but I handed him my copy of his 2006 Topps Update All-Star card to sign. 

Two years later (when Twins Fest was in Blaine, following the collapse of the Metrodome roof), I sat in on the kids' Q&A with my friend Carl Johnson, and was lucky enough to get a question in for Mauer myself. It wasn’t what his favorite food or color was like any other kid wanted to ask him. It was baseball-specific.

“My name is Theo, and I wanted to ask if you think you’re the next player to hit .400?” 

“Woof, wow. I don’t know, I can definitely shoot for it. That would be something but I think I am more worried about trying to win a World Series first,” Mauer answered. 

Years went on, and the interactions halted until TwinsFest 2019. It was a dark day for me, personally, but going to TwinsFest was the light in it. There was only one goal for me. Getting an autograph of Mauer’s on the college student newspaper article I wrote on reflecting on his retirement from the game, two months earlier. He signed a copy and I gave him one to read.

Four years later and finally a professional journalist, the opportunity to interview Mauer came again on his team Hall of Fame induction day this past August. Coming full circle from interviewing him as a kid. 

Now, with many friends, we will get to see our baseball icon, who may have let us down as a player sometimes, but never as a person.  That’s why his Hall of Fame induction is hard to describe to so many who were kids during his career--and who are now adults, seeing the dream come true. 

What are your memories of Mauer? How does he fit into your image of the Twins, five years and three division titles after his retirement? Feel free to share some personal stories in the comments.

View full article

[adjacent]

Did you see the swing in that clip when he was a 4-5 year old? The same swing!