The 4 and 5 were in line with other championship teams? Just looking at their stats I have a hard time believing it, unless you say #3 is empty and call Straker a #4. Even then, what they really put out there for 3 and 4 was amazingly putrid:
Smithson - 20 GS, 109 IP, 5.94 ERA, 1.505 WHIP, 78 ERA+, -0.4 bWAR;
Niekro - 18 GS, 96.1 IP, 6.26 ERA, 1.661 WHIP, 74 ERA+, -1.0 WAR
Carlton - 7 GS; 6.70 ERA, 69 ERA+, 1.791 WHIP, -0.5 WAR
Portugal - 7 GS, 7.77 ERA, 60 ERA+, 1.864 WHIP, -1.0 WAR
That was interesting stuff about Reardon. I remember being underwhelmed by our big acquisition during the regular season, but he was pretty darned good in the post-season (despite blowing saves in the first two games against Detroit.)