Another way to look at it, AL WAR rankings each year for 10 years. (2005-2014) plus a few accomplishments. 2005: 31st. 2006: tied for 4th (1st batting title ever for an AL catcher, All Star, Silver Slugger, 6th in MVP voting) 2007: tied for 28th 2008: 6th (2nd batting title ever for an AL catcher, All Star, Silver Slugger, Gold Glove, 4th in MVP voting) 2009: 2nd (3rd batting title ever for an AL catcher, All Star, Silver Slugger, Gold Glove, 1st guy in 30 years to lead AL in BA/OBP/SLG and first AL catcher to ever do it, MVP). 2010: 10th (All Star, Silver Slugger, Gold Glove, 8th in MVP voting). 2011: 86th (only played half a season). 2012: tied for 10th (All Star, 19th in MVP voting) 2013: tied for 10th while only playing 113 games. Guy he tied with played 160. (All Star, Silver Slugger). Those were the pre-concussion years, mostly catcher years. That's 9 years of pretty great work and an average of 4.2 WAR with 6 out of 9 years being in top 10 in AL WAR. 2014: 82nd (post concussion, position switch).