Not sure in what context you mean "bad comp." The question revolved around "most-ballyhooed in-season debut for a prospect." Wasn't a comparison to any other players based on ability, track record in the minors, or anywhere else. Calling up the number 3 overall pick mid-season just two years after being drafted brought with it a certain amount of hype, even if it was 20+ years ago. Obviously, the amount of information available publicly for baseball fans was not nearly what it is today. For those that remember how the Strib was laid out then, Sunday was the big day for baseball reporting beyond the Twins. I'm sure Baseball America or other baseball-exclusive periodicals were available, but for many of us growing up here, the Strib was it. There was about 4 full pages dedicated to baseball if I remember correctly. A couple of pages alone listed the batting stats for almost every prominent big-leaguer. Another area was dedicated to showing the stats of all the minor league teams in the Twins' system. That was about it as far as minor-league / prospect coverage went back in the day. We weren't able to scroll though Seth's Twitter timeline to get detailed info about every prized prospects ABs like we are lucky enough to be able to do so often nowadays. I was at the Dome on the day McCarty made his debut. McCarty was the subject of an almost ruthless amount of ribbing, from players, coaches, and the manager from the nanosecond he arrived at the ballpark. Kirby Puckett, who in November of 1989 became the first $3MM player in MLB history, was all over McCarty. "Hey man, new sheriff's in town! Comin' to take Puck's job! New sheriff in town!" I musta heard Puck say that about 10 times that day.