As a society we have to set limits on punishment for specific crimes, taking into consideration the damage done, the victims, the circumstances, etc. What this young man did at 15 was indeed horrible, and his victim may suffer permanent psychological harm. But if this young man has received psychological treatment, if he has been punished, if he has showed no signs of repeating the behavior, what then? Do we still condemn him for life? Is he for some reason barred from baseball, other sports? Can he be a fireman? A soldier? Some of our soldiers have done far worse than this, and returned home as heroes. I agree that drafting this guy would make me uncomfortable, but that's mainly because I don't know if the young man has learned to understand what he did, that it was wrong, that he can never do anything like that again. If he is an incorrigible child molester, then fine, ban him, shun him. But if he has learned to be horrified by his own behavior, if it was a temporary dark place he was in, then I cannot in good conscience condemn him forever.