"Here's my (over?)reaction... as much as we all want Buxton to succeed - he clearly is not ready. He especially had several very hittable pitches during that AB with a guy on second" Concur, in a larger sense. What concerned me most about Buxton last year, and in an extremely small sample yesterday, wasn't so much the K's, or the tendency to not recognize breaking pitches. It's his inability to do much with hittable pitches inside the strike zone. So far, he rarely makes loud contact. Lots of young hitters come up to the big leagues, and often get fooled at the plate, being made to look foolish at times. But they also show the ability to punish pitches that should be hit. Buxton simply hasn't shown the ability to do that. I hope it changes, but so far, he's not shown the talent to hit at the big league level.