I think the issue for Joe started when he grew late. A 6'2" catcher is plausible, a 6'5" catcher is not. Higher profile catchers stand a greater chance of getting beat up and a lesser chance of throwing out runners. When Joe was drafted, he was not 6'5". When he was learning the position, he was shorter yet. In his earlier career, he threw out runners at or above the league percentage. That declined as he advanced in years and stature. At his prime, he was a really good catcher and a great hitter. Prior to Joe, a great catcher batted .280 and threw out 40+ percent of runners (Johnny Bench was 6'1"). In his prime, Joe batted .350 and threw out 40+ percent of runners. Yadi Molina is someone that I would say is one of the best catchers in the game today. He's 5'11", bats .287 and throws out 45-50 percent of the runners. Joe batting .350 and throwing out 40 percent of runners was insane...but so is catching when you are 6'5". Best catcher ever? Roy Campanella - 5'9", batted .276 and threw out 57% of runners. JMO.