You want players with high OBP batting at the top of the order. The only teams with 1B with better OBP percentages are: Atlanta San Fran St. Louis Cincinnati Chicago (AL) Boston Mauer would be batting near the top of the order for most teams if you are looking at first basemen. If you include all positions, Mauer would still be hitting at the top of the order for over half of the league. Now, if what you meant to say was, Mauer isn't hitting for power like the typical first baseman, so he should not be batting cleanup or in the middle of the order, sure. Good thing he isn't!