1) Santana is proof you should never go with the herd when evaluating anything. Make your own decisions and judgments. 2) You say reputation matters ... but then you say people have Santana wrong. Santana has never thrown a tantrum, he has always helped out his team, and he has always performed well. If anyone has an issue with his "reputation" the problem is THEM. Historically, Santana is an ace, it's only in people's minds where he is a #3. Forget that. I was always high on Santana and I'm not at all surprised by his tenure as a Twin. I'm disappointed others chose to see something other than Ervin when judging him -- and still do. Forget the herd. Do you want to surround yourself with the best, or do you want to be the most popular? This is the question around Santana. The Twins, for once, gave the right answer (albeit for probably the wrong reason -- $$).