According to Baseball Reference, from 2015 through 2016, Brian Dozier has 3 walk-off home runs, 13 tying home runs and 24 go-ahead home runs among his 70 home run total. (I pieced this together, maybe someone has better information) That seems like a special bat and perhaps a #1 starter is undervaluing Mr. Dozier just a bit. Remember, a #1 starter pitches every 5th day, but the #2 and #3 starter may need the bat provided by Mr. Dozier. (I realize there are some problems with the totals, because some home-runs are probably double counted. For instance, a walk-off home run may also be counted as a go-ahead home-run.)