Not insane, but I think you may be on the Kool-Aid. "every team" is a complete stretch.
Polanco was a proven switch-hitter with positional versatility and clubhouse leadership. The Twins gave him up for an injured reliever, a pitcher who’s already off the roster, and a couple of prospects who might pan out.
Gonzales has been solid lately—credit where it’s due—but saying every team would take him over Polanco “straight up” total exaggeration.
What did we get?
Anthony DeSclafani: Never threw a pitch. Out for the season. Gone.
Justin Topa: Injured. Again. Able to pitch in 2025 after being out most of 2024. FA now.
Gabriel Gonzalez: Still in Double-A. Solid tools, but hitting around .250 with questions about plate discipline.
Dylan Moore? Utility guy, replacement level.