IowaBeancounter

If Miranda continues hitting close to his post all-star clip (.360 ave & .950 OPS) he should be ROY. Rodriquez was injured, but post all-star he is at .208 ave. & .672 OPS. Can someone explain why Miranda only has a bWAR of 1.2?

As I understand it replay requires clear and convincing evidence to overrule a call on the field. To me this means that if 10 different umpires review a play all 10 should come to the same conclusion. For a fan you would accept the call whether it was for or against your team. (I have seem several Blue Jay fans stating that they believe Merrifield should have been called out.) Either MLB or the review crew this week decided to put an emphasis on catchers blocking the plate. I believe that of all the calls reviewed the Sanchez Merrifield was the closest to being allowed to stand. Since this play now become the test to measure future calls, MLB is in a bind. If another crew does not follow the Sanchez Merrifield decision, MLB will be admitting that the evidence was not clear and convincing and Merrifield should have been ruled out. If they continue to follow the Sanchez Merrifield rule, MLB will be encouraging players to make contact with catcher on any close play, that the catcher at anytime had a foot in foul territory, and they should be called safe. The ultimate Karma of this play is that one of MLBs powerhouses, NYY, NYM, LAD or HOU, would have a similar call go against them during the playoffs that cost them a game or the series. Toronto was given a gift to the detriment of not only the Twins, but every other wild card contender. During the broadcast I believe they said that the Twins had the tie breaker against almost every wild card team, but Toronto didn't. This means that if Toronto beats another wild card team by a game, the other team will be eliminated or will have a lower seed. I hope MLB reaps what it has sown. Go Twins

Bullpen is completely changed. Which reliever with get option (or DFAd), when Mahle is added?

I was expecting more experienced players to traded to avoid losing them in the rule 5 draft. I think Povich was drafted in 2021 not 2011.

I believe that most of a catcher's value is how he handles the pitchers. I don't know how to find the Twins' pitchers ERA when pitching to Jeffers or Sanchez, based on my eye test I would expect that they would have a lower stats when pitching to Jeffers. JMHO

I'm in agreement with letting Smeltzer start the 8th, he had already faced the top of the order for the 3rd time through the lineup. Why not let him try to get the 6,7,8 batters in the 8th for a 3rd time. What I really don't understand is using Duffey, prior to last night he had 3 appearances vs KC for 2.1 innings, giving up 4 runs for an ERA of 15.43 (after last night his ERA vs KC is 18.90). IMHO KC has seen Duffey enough that they know what to swing at and what to lay off and Duffey knows this so he ends up grooving pitches. In Duffey's 14 non KC appearances he has pitched 15 innings with an ERA of 1.80. Duffey is an OK reliever, just not against KC.

Dman 4,908 Gold Caretaker Posted 1 hour ago "Doesn't the trade of Donaldson really include Mitch Garver to some degree as well? The Twins couldn't get Kiner-Falefa without giving up Garver so in the end the trade was. Garver, Kiner-Falefa, Rortvedt and Donalson for Sanchez, Urshela and Henriquez? I don't think you can completely leave the loss of Garver out of that trade IMO. That seems like a lot to give up to get rid of Donaldson" The way I look at in total, after all the trades and signings, the Twins gave up Garver, Donaldson and Rortvedt to receive Sanchez, Urshela and Henriquez and freed up enough money to sign Correa. Kiner-Falefa was a trade chip received and the traded. From my point view as of today, this is a win for the Twins.

I don't like the decision, as I believe that Lewis' bat and speed is a difference maker. In the 11 games he was up the Twins were 6-5 and I believe Lewis was instrumental in 2 of the wins, the 12-8 win vs Cleveland where he accounted for 5 of the runs and the 3-1 win against Oakland where he scored 2 runs. In the 11 games the Twins scored 32 runs and Lewis was involved in 8 of those runs (runs + RBI - HR) or 25% of the production. i believe that Lewis is capable of playing 3rd, outfield and if necessary 1st. I know some believe that it is a waste of his athletic abilities to play first, but right now his bat is more important to the Twins, so what's wrong with him starting at first when facing a left hander, Arraez would be available to pinch hit for Urshella or Celestino and Lewis could fill in their positions, with Arraez taking 1st. Just my 2 cents. An additional point is that baring an injury Lewis is in St. Paul for 10 days.

"Don't tell that to Ron Washington." I know Ron Washington said that, but I also know that I played 1st when I was young (youth and Legion ball) and it was easier than right field as I wasn't fleet afoot. I was tall and left handed. There is a reason that athletes transition to first as they get older or are injured (Mauer). 1st is the least demanding of the positions in regards to speed and arm strength.

I want him to stay up as well. Given the Twins 1st base situation I would give him a try there. I believe that 1st is one of the easiest positions to play. Arraez has has done ok, but on hard grounders (to 1st or 3rd) he has tendency to swing his glove to his side and "hope" the ball finds it. As a result Baseballsavant has Arraez giving up 6 runs. I believe that Lewis could move around the diamond 1st, 3rd, SS & outfield and be an average or plus defender. Just my 2 cents. Go Twins