It's the same risk issue Rocco just had with Moran, light's out for one inning then struggled number 2, I would say he should let him at least start the 6th but have someone warming up immediately.
Cleveland is currently in 2nd and winning right now, if we lose and they win the lead is 3.5 games I believe. They've got the pitching to contend but to your point, their hitting has to pick up.