This is quite the list. Let's break it down. Verlander: $28M per season for the next 4 years with a 5th year vesting option. Is 32, has made $20 and $28M the last two seasons, was injured this year, has a FIP over those 2 years of 3.73 with declining strikeout numbers. How's that contract looking going forward? Scherzer: How does he even make the list? He is in the 1st year of a gigantic contract. He technically has 6 years left on his deal, but he will be paid for 14 more years. What will the Nationals this of this contract later as they are paying him $15M per season until he is 47 years old? Grienke: One of the few that actually looks good. At age 31 he is having his finest season of his career. With only 3 years @ ~25M apiece left, he could be worth it for the entire length of his contract. Kershaw: In the middle of this prime at age 27, he does not belong on this list. Yes, he makes a ton of money, $35M per, but will become a free agent following his 32 year old season. Felix: Age 29, has 4 years left on his deal worth ~$27M. He has certainly been worth his contract so far and even with a down year is an ace. His contract is set up well. Lester: Having a fine year at age 31 in the first year of a 6 year deal with the Cubs. Has he been worth it this year, certainly. But his contract, which averages ~25M takes him through age 36. Calling him worth it so far, not even 20% into his contract, seems premature. Hamels: He is in year 3 of 6 of his deal. At age 31, he is certainly been worth it thus far. His contract takes him through age 34 and averages $23.5M a season. So on this list you have Kershaw and Felix, who are under the age of 30, still in their prime and still with the team they were drafted by. Lester and Scherzer two players who signed deals long deals who are still in the 1st year of their deal. Grienke and Hamels, both in the middle of their contracts, both signed through 34 and both playing very well, and then there is Verlander....who very much looks like an albatross going forward. I the 5 year contract Sabathia signed in 2011 worth $23M per season, he was above average for exactly 1 of them, 2012. Injury or not he has been a below average pitcher with another year and possibly 2 left on his deal. In your original post you said the Twins could "easily sign" David Price and have $10M left over to sign a real #2 starter. At age 30 at the level that Price is playing at, you are realistically looking at 28-30M per season, for 6-7 years. That's not an easy contract for anyone to sign. The Twins aren't the Dodgers or the Yankees. Who is this solid #2 they are going to sign for $10M that is going to be better than Hughes/Santana? How long is that contract going to be?