AJ defied the calendar in 2015 at age 38 to an even greater extent than Torii did at age 40. While at some point we can expect a decline, the question everyone interested in his services will ask is whether the decline will be subtle or dramatic. Given his long career, there is a pretty good chance he will be at least 80% of what he produced last year. He had well over 400 plate appearances, so it isn't like he played twice a week, more like he was platooned, which would be the exact situation he would find himself in for the Twins in 2016. In order, I would like to see a good catcher like Lucroy or Wieters acquired, preferring Lucroy as a better blend of health, cost, defense and offense. Second, a good to excellent prospect (less than a full year of service time) and third, a one-year contract for someone to share time with Suzuki, with a lefty hitter probably getting more time than Zuke. My biggest reservation about Pierzynski is his defense, particularly his throwing and the small risk that he will regress dramatically.