Caratini's OPS last season vs. RH pitching was .726, Larnach .759 and Clemens .762, not like there is worlds of difference IMHO. I agree that having a LH hitter or two in the lineup is a pretty good idea. However, on the Twins there aren't many LH hitters that merit starting against a lefty. The choices would be Outman, Larnach, Gray and Clemens. Given those options, I'd take Caratini, who is probably a better defender than Bell. I'm not fond of the roster, but given what is there, I think that should be the starting nine vs. LH starters.