He's the kind of hitter you don't give up on, IMO, until he's had absolutely every opportunity. The ability to really punish a pitch when it's where and how you want it isn't there for just everybody. I remember at Spring Training a couple of years ago, I arrived at the back field to see someone power a ball over the right field fence. "That's Murphy, right?", I asked one of the young men in a Twins uniform on the aluminum bleachers, to confirm what I thought without a roster sheet in hand. "Yeah. He can hit," the guy said in genuine admiration. The players know. That doesn't guarantee success of course; there are a lot of Max Murphys out there, and most still don't make it. Age 24 in high-A isn't good, but still they should stick with him.