Curious because you're approaching the situation with an open mind, right? Lol j/k! Here's the first one: "The guy has earned it," Ryan said of the former 14th overall draft pick in 2008. "I find it almost humorous that people are talking about service time, starting the clock. We didn't trade Span and Revere to stall the next guy. Ryan indisputably contradicts himself here, revealing that through a handful of nearly meaningless exhibition games, Hicks somehow "earned" a job that was his by default the moment that Span and Revere were traded. And to ensure that he strips himself of any lingering credibility after his 'pretty darn good pitcher' comment, Ryan reveals that he considers the very concept of service time laughable. O... k. But there's more. "Are we trying to win, or what are we doing?" Ryan said. "Can you imagine if we sent somebody out that did what the kid did, and I had to look at (Josh) Willingham and (Justin) Morneau and (Glen) Perkins and (Joe) Mauer and those guys that are trying to win, and I'm going to stop that guy? I just don't believe in that. I hear this stuff. Not here." And now Ryan blazes past the absurdity of the flat earth service time denier bit, escalating to some sort of weird humanitarian zone where he is somehow morally, almost tearfully obligated to make a personnel decision that will let him socialize with highly compensated veterans who are apparently living in abject terror of losing 93 games instead of 83. By his own assertion (or at this point, admission), Terry Ryan is trying to win. By any standard that I can either observe or imagine, he's failing so far this season. So that tends to undermine his entire premise for any personnel decisions allegedly predicated on that goal. Ryan was good in his first incarnation as GM. The jury is still out on his second, which may turn out well. And obviously he feels obligated to help sell tickets by putting a positive spin on things, which is perfectly understandable. Good for him. That being said, Terry Ryan shot his credibility in the foot when he mocked any scepticism regarding the decision to rely on a double A player who is now undeniably one of the worst in the majors. My hope is that he earns that credibility back with a 'sell' trade like the one he managed with AJ.