That's a two way street, and the burden of 'proof', such as it is, officially passed from the 'fire Gardy' sentiment to the 'don't fire Gardy' sentiment when Gardenhire was retained for 2014 after 3 consecutive 90+ - loss seasons. That just doesn't happen. As Gleeman noted again recently, non-expansion managers since WWII don't get to come back for another season after that. Pretty much ever. Yes, TK did, but he had more WS rings than Gardenhire does playoff series wins. And what's been the result of every manager in that span returning after three 90-loss seasons? Another 90+ loss season. Even so, if you want my reasons why he should go, they're probably pretty unsurprising and perhaps even unconvincing, but here goes: Irrational contempt for sabremetrics, lineup- and roster-debilitating pathological fear of losing the DH, obsessive/compulsive hoarding of light-hitting middle infielders, and my unprovable suspicion that while not a leading cause, Rick Anderson's mandatory presence beside Gardenhire really is part of the reason the pitching has been inconsistent and then consistently awful for years. He's probably a good manager even with those faults, and a likeable fellow in any case. But he's had thirteen seasons and some talented rosters yet gone nowhere in the postseason except the year he inherited the team from Kelly. Still, if there are compelling reasons the Twins, not known as a terribly cutting-edge franchise, should ignore 70 years of virtually unanimous conventional baseball wisdom by bringing him back yet again, I'm all ears. Or in this case, eyes.