What would the return be on Revere?

[Brock Beauchamp]

From Fangraphs

 

Career BA/OBP/BABIP.....(OBP-BA differentials):

 

Boggs: 328/415/344 (+.087)

Cobb: 366/433/378 (+.067)

Carew: 328/393/359 (+.065)

Puckett: 318/360/342 (+.042)

Brock: 293/343/338 (+.040)

 

Revere: 288/327/316 (+.039)

Your math is bad. Brock's ISO Discipline is .050 (like I said) and Revere has raised his ISO Discipline almost ten points in the last few days. We'll see if it holds.

 

Out of your list, that leaves Puckett. That's a pretty small list. No one is claiming that riding a high BABIP to the Hall of Fame is impossible. I'm only stating that it's incredibly unlikely.

 

And we shouldn't even be talking about Cobb. There's nothing worth comparing between a dead ball era player and a modern player. The game is completely different.