I don't think I ever said they had comparable ceilings. Both had success in an abbreviated rookie campaign. Both saw their OPS drop about .150 in their second season. Both showed improvement over their rookie season in their third season. Seems like a pretty parallel path to me. Parallel, NOT equal. As for the playing time, don't even get me started. It isn't up to Vargas when he plays. All he can do is produce when he does. And he has. His career OPS is higher than Mauer's (the guy who plays Vargas' position) since the time Vargas came into the league. And although I haven't checked, it's likely as good or better than other players that have been used as the DH during that time. I'm not even sure who that be. Vargas has probably had more DH at bats than any other single player over the last 3 years plus. When he plays, he mashes the ball. He did show good obp ability last year, so it is a skill he has. As I said, I'm not sure why he isn't this year. I think he will with more playing time. He's striking out 20% of the time, which is considerably better than he ever has before. So, is that not also showing progress as a hitter? As for Pressly, you are valuing his ability over his results. It's your list, you are certainly able to rank as you please. But I guess I would expect a list like this to be results oriented.