I like this approach. It definitely allows for some subjectivity, but I think it tells a valuable part of the story. In this view, a sort-of-clunker appearance and a mega-clunker appearance are equals. Long-term, you'd have to establish rules for a successful/unsuccessful appearance and you'd, of course, have to be ready for all sorts of arguing about why the rules are wrong. subjective or not, i think this is a cool exercise... ...and I think we'd all be less concerned about this bullpen if the offense was doing its job. 3.4 runs per game has put the pitching staff in an impossible spot.