Some thought the rotation would be really good this year because of 2015. Used the same kind of argument. Anyway, to answer the question, for me, that's a yes. It really is tough to envision a combo of those pitchers being a decent rotation. -May is very likely going to stay a reliever. Even if that changes, it's going to take time to get him ready for the rotation again. -Berrios doesn't look close, not sure he'll be really ready next year. -Santiago? No. -Gibson? No. -Duffey? No. -Santana? Yes And without know what Dozier would get back, that part is incomplete. That's a very shaky list of options to roll with. There's a whole lot of no's in there and the look back to rotation 2015 as a hope it might be good in 2017 is flawed. The same rotation that was decent for part of 2015 was almost the same rotation that was horrible in 2014. So while keeping the one pitcher we should be able to reasonably count on can seem appealing, when looking at the talent on this team and remembering we're likely going to lose 100 games this year even with him on the roster (and performing well), might as well trade him and hope to get younger guys in that will help in the future.