You know he's "played hurt many times" how, exactly? For the record, he's played 150 games in a season exactly once. As many as 140 games in a season another 4 times. That's 9 seasons of under 140 games, out of 14, not including 2018 (which will be under 130.) He is now a part time player, there is really no disputing that, even disregarding the injury time off. I also dispute "he is as capable of hitting .300 now as ever." He's done it once since 2013, just barely, and the other seasons since '13 are all under .280. And of course the BA comes with almost no power. And call me a simpleton, but I don't think "gravitas" wins baseball games. I stand by my opinion...it shouldn't be up to Mauer whether or not he plays for the Twins in 2019. If he wants to play, it should be up to the front office to decide if he's the best option to help win games. And if that's the best the front office can do, well, that's not a very encouraging sign.