Dozier, Plouffe, Mauer, and Hunter are only candidates for the 5 hole if you move them from spots above the 5 hole. Someday, maybe Rosario is a candidate, ideally that isn't now. The rest of your list? Are you seriously suggesting the problem can be solved by putting Shane Robinson in the lineup regularly? Hermann? They are missing middle of the order bats. They don't have ANY (given what Mauer has become), much less multiple options plus whoever is occupying those spots now.