I'm lazy today so I'm not going to find the article to support this, but haven't teams that have one player accounting for 20% or more of the payroll struggled to make the playoffs, and never won a World Series? Manny at 8/250 would mean the payroll would have to jump to over $150m before he would be less than that threshold. You can't buy a good team in the long run, and giving that high of a percent of your payroll to one player is asking for trouble. Injuries happen, he has ben called out for not giving it everything, why risk it? We had a catcher that was on a HOF path and people could deal with it when it didn't turn out, I really don't want to deal with all the bitching again in 4-5 years.