Problem is, Doumit isn't a very good DH either, not compared to other DHs....now, compared to the options the Twins have, and teh fact he can also be the backup catcher, I'm good with him being on the roster. Personally, I believe catcher defense is one of the last great myths of baseball. Sure, framing might matter, but all the rest is probably BS. As for Mauer, he looks great compared to Doumit, but that does make him good at being a catcher. As far as I can tell, his defensive stats have been well below average for this year and last. I don't watch enough other baseball to compare him to other catchers, but those who do, don't score him so well anymore.