As a hitter, Mauer would be the 4th best offensive 1B in all of baseball......I'd take that right now. If someone came to the Twins, and said, here, take the 4th best hitting 1B in all of baseball, the Twins would say yes. Does he lose some value in a position change? Probably, but I don't think it is as big a drop as people are arguing. Unless, of course, people really think it is LIKELY Mauer will stay healthy and productive as a catcher, few (some) have. 1. I think he'd hit better not catching 2. Even if he hits the same, he's still one of the best 1B on the planet 3. The drop off from Mauer to the next catcher in MN is probably a big deal, I agree with this. 4. Mauer is useless if hurt, or needing a lot of rest. He is signed for quite some time. I'd prefer 1B, the position where he is less likely to get hurt. For me, I'd have Mauer catch 60 or so games, at most at this point.