Market rate = the price, not an overpay...and they have plenty of cash sittig in a giant pile.and I've covered this in numerous threads..... Hicks, imo, will never hit well. Arcia is an iffy fielder. Ellsbury gives them 3-5 wins over what they got this year from CF, move him to LF when Buxton is up, you have an elite defensive OF. He has stolen 50 of 52 attempts this year, he's not in decline. The leaves RF as your only LT question mark in the OF, with Hicks and Arcia battling for that position. Basically, you sign him because he, and I know this is not what they are supposed to be doing now, makes them better next year and teh year after and the year after. Had they signed a legit SP last year, and sign Ellsbury this year, they are basically at 80-82 wins, before adding Sano, Rosario, a decent 1B or DH. You sign players to make the team better. And people keep saying "well, Boston isn't signing him, they must know something "....wouldn't that apply to 100% of the free agents? By that logic, you'd never sign any FA ever.