This completely ignores context, and that Dozier is signed for 2 years, and JDL is controlled for 6, imo. If you really think JDL is a three, you make that deal all day. If you are only 75% sure, maybe you want a flyer on top of that.....but unless you think the Twins are in the playoffs this year, what good is 1 year of Dozier? Before you answer "you can always trade him later"....I assume, since you won't do it for a number three, you'd want more than that, what would it take later?