Precisely, so suggesting that it is "fair" to give a guy a deal based on some abstract idea of his worth seems kind of silly when, in reality, no one in Dozier's situation makes anywhere near that amount. The better question is, who does Dozier compare to and what do they get paid in their situation? To spycake's point, Dozier is not on the same level as Kipnis, so paying him that much would be an overpayment, not a bargain.